Claim Phone Numbers ACE                                                                          866-840-1223 AIG                                                                           877-802-5246 American Western Home                                          800-375-2075 Capital Indemnity                                                      800-475-4450     Drive Insurance from Progressive                             800-925-2886                      Encompass                                                               800-588-7400 The Hartford                                                             800-327-3636 Hawkeye-Security                                                     877-429-5185 Markel Insurance                                                      800-362-7535 MO Employers Mutual                                              800-442-0591 Nautilus                                                                    800-358-5178 Safeco                                                                     800-332-3226 Scottsdale                                                                800-423-7675 Seneca                                                                    212-277-3490 St. Paul Travelers                                                    800-238-6225 United Fire and Casualty                                         800-343-9131 United States Liability                                              800-523-5545 Western Heritage                                                    800-873-9442 Western World                                                        201-847-8600